Pehli Nazar Ka Pyaar is a love story set in Shimla. One day Anju comes from America to visit Shimla with her friends. Ajay saves Anju in a fall from a mountain height and it is love at first sight for him. He doesn't know that she is engaged but he proposes marriage to her.
Anju's boyfriend Rahul also lands up in Shimla and she starts to realise that she cares more for Ajay than Rahul. Rahul feels she is getting close Ajay and calls her family from America.
Anju's family tries to persuade her that Rahul is the best match for her and now it is about how Ajay and Anju try to get together despite pressure from Rahul and Anju's family.